Between majoritarian confrontation and consociational democracy in a decolonizing territory : the case of New Caledonia-Kanaky (2024-2026)


This article examines the deepening political crisis in New Caledonia–Kanaky, understood as a confrontation between a resurgent French assimilationist logic and the decolonial consociationalism underpinning the Nouméa Accord. It argues that the 2024 Kanak uprising was triggered by the French government’s unilateral attempt to unfreeze the restricted electoral roll, thereby breaching the consensus-based framework established by the successive agreements. The article critically analyses the “Bougival–Élysée–Oudinot” texts, arguing that they progressively dismantle power-sharing institutions, subsume Indigenous rights within a broader and supposedly inclusive “Caledonian” identity, and replace a process of external decolonization with a form of symbolic internal autonomy. The rejection of the proposed “Bougival–Élysée–Oudinot” agreement has resulted in an institutional and political deadlock, while leaving the Nouméa Accord formally in force. To overcome this impasse, the article calls for a return to negotiations grounded in consociational principles. Ultimately, it proposes a model of full sovereignty for New Caledonia-Kanaky, coupled with a constitutional framework of interdependence with France, in accordance with the United Nations’ decolonization framework and with the aim of securing an inclusive and sustainable peace.

Chauchat, M. (2026). Between majoritarian confrontation and consociational democracy in a decolonizing territory : the case of New Caledonia-Kanaky (2024-2026). Small States & Territories, 9(2), 439-462.

https://www.um.edu.mt/library/oar/handle/123456789/150621

Between_majoritarian_confrontation_and_consociational_democracy_Small States and territories MChauchat 2026

Menu